On this page
At dusk on a porch with no outlet nearby, a lantern that charges itself from daylight is the difference between a dark step and a lit one, and the choice in a metal vs plastic solar lantern comes down to frame, shade, charge time and runtime. Metal frames take knocks and hold their shape through seasons outdoors, while plastic shades do not rust. This guide compares the frame and shade material, the stated charge and runtime figures, and the warranty term of each listing, so the choice fits the spot where the lantern will hang.
SolarKitHQ earns a commission when you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate disclosure.
The quick answer
For a lantern that stays outside through rain and snow, a metal frame with a stated IP code and a 12 months warranty is the stronger pick, and the TomCare lantern is the one listing here that puts those together. For a shade that hangs from a branch or a hook and moves around the yard, a plastic shade on a metal frame gives the same solar charging with less to carry. Plastic alone suits a sheltered porch or a seasonal display, where the lantern comes inside between uses. The MATAHUM pair shows the edge case: metal frames with flameless LED candles and no solar panel, so the pair needs AAA batteries and suits indoor decor rather than a solar setup.
Metal vs plastic solar lantern: the 4 listings side by side
| Lantern | Frame and shade | Charge and runtime | Warranty |
|---|---|---|---|
| TomCare Flickering Flame Solar Lantern, 2 pack | Metal frame, poly plastic sides with glass effect | Charges in 6-8 hours, 10-12-hour runtime, IP65 code stated | 12 months |
| DERAYSION Solar Lantern, 2 pack | Stainless metal frame, real glass shade | Charges in 6-8 hours, 8-10-hour runtime | 1 year manufacturer |
| GIGALUMI Solar Hanging Lantern, 12 pack | Crackle glass shade, stainless steel hooks | Charges in 8-12 hours, 6-8-hour runtime | 90 days |
| MATAHUM Decorative Metal Lantern, 2 pack | Black metal frame, no glass, flameless LED candles | No solar charging, 3 AAA batteries per candle | Not stated |
All numbers here are manufacturer claims from the listings, not our measurements.
The gear: 4 lanterns ranked
The listings below run from the strongest outdoor pick to the indoor-only pair, ranked on stated runtime, weather code, warranty and material.
Top pick: TomCare Flickering Flame Solar Lantern
The listing states a metal frame with a rustproof finish, four sides of poly plastic with a glass effect, and a bronze finish with a hook for hanging or tabletop use. Charging takes 6-8 hours in direct sunlight, and the stated runtime is 10-12 hours, the longest runtime among the 4 listings here. An IP65 code is stated, and the listing states a 12 months warranty. The flickering flame effect gives a warm yellow glow, and the light turns on at dusk and off at dawn on its own. At 4.7 inches by 4.7 inches by 8.3 inches, the lantern fits a patio table or a shepherds hook.
Also strong: DERAYSION Solar Lantern
The listing states a stainless metal frame with a real glass shade, a wall mount bracket, and a hook and screws for mounting on a fence or porch. Charging takes 6-8 hours, and the stated runtime is 8-10 hours. The listing states a 1 year manufacturer warranty. Built-in light sensors turn the lantern on at dusk and off at dawn. At 11.0 inches by 6.6 inches by 6.6 inches, this is the largest lantern in the set, and the listing describes it as weatherproof rated for rain and snow.
Seasonal pick: GIGALUMI Solar Hanging Lantern
The listing states a 12 pack of hanging lanterns with crackle glass shades and stainless steel hanging hooks, in green, for garden, yard, patio, porch and fence use. Charging takes 8-12 hours of full daylight, and the stated runtime is 6-8 hours overnight, with warm white, cool white and color-changing light modes and a dusk-to-dawn sensor. The listing states a 90 days warranty. The listing gives 2 sizes: the spec table lists 2.3 inches by 2.3 inches by 3.5 inches while the size field lists 2.4 inches by 2.4 inches by 5.2 inches, so check the size before hanging a full set.
Indoor-only pair: MATAHUM Decorative Metal Lantern
The listing states a pair of black metal lanterns with no glass, a hanging ring on each, and 2 flameless LED candles with a remote control. The large lantern measures 5.5 inches by 5.5 inches by 15 inches, and the small lantern measures 4.7 inches by 4.7 inches by 11 inches. Each candle takes 3 AAA batteries, and the remote takes 1 CR2025 battery. No solar panel and no charging time are stated, so this pair runs on batteries rather than sunlight, and no warranty term is stated. The open frame suits a tabletop, shelf, mantel or covered patio as decor, and the listing advises moving the lanterns indoors in strong winds or extreme weather.
How to choose the best metal vs plastic solar lantern
Match the frame to the spot
A lantern that hangs on an open fence through rain and snow needs a metal frame and a stated weather code, and the TomCare listing pairs a rustproof metal frame with an IP65 code. A lantern under a covered porch or on a sheltered table can use a plastic shade, since the roof takes the weather instead of the lantern. The DERAYSION listing pairs a stainless metal frame with a real glass shade and a wall mount bracket, which suits a fixed spot on a fence or porch.
Match the shade to the use
Glass shades give a clear glow and hold their shape, and the DERAYSION and GIGALUMI listings both use glass. Poly plastic sides with a glass effect, as on the TomCare lantern, give the look of glass with less risk of a break if the lantern falls. A lantern with no glass at all, like the MATAHUM pair, suits indoor decor where the open frame shows the candle glow. Check the shade material in the listing before hanging a lantern in a busy walkway. See the solar lantern vs LED camping lantern comparison for a camping use.
Compare charge time and runtime together
A lantern that charges in 6-8 hours and runs 10-12 hours, like the TomCare listing, gives the longest runtime in this set. A lantern that charges in 8-12 hours and runs 6-8 hours, like the GIGALUMI listing, needs a longer stretch of daylight for a shorter night of light. Place the lantern where direct sunlight falls for the charge time the listing states. Keep the panel clear so it takes in daylight for the full charge time; the how to clean solar lights guide covers the routine.
Check the warranty term
The TomCare listing states a 12 months warranty, the DERAYSION listing states a 1 year manufacturer warranty, and the GIGALUMI listing states a 90 days warranty. The MATAHUM listing states no warranty term. A longer stated warranty gives a longer window for a claim with the maker.
FAQ: power away from the grid
Which lasts longer outdoors, a metal or a plastic solar lantern?
Metal frames hold their shape through knocks and weather, and the TomCare and DERAYSION listings pair metal frames with stated warranties of 12 months and 1 year. Plastic shades do not rust, but the listings here pair plastic with metal frames rather than using plastic alone. For a lantern that stays outside all year, the metal-frame listings in this guide are the stronger pick.
How long do these solar lanterns run after charging?
The TomCare listing states 10-12 hours after 6-8 hours of charging, the DERAYSION listing states 8-10 hours after 6-8 hours of charging, and the GIGALUMI listing states 6-8 hours after 8-12 hours of charging. The MATAHUM pair has no solar charging and runs on AAA batteries instead.
What does the IP65 code on the TomCare lantern mean?
The TomCare listing states an IP65 code alongside a rustproof metal frame and poly plastic sides. The listing describes the lantern as suited to rain and snow.
Can a metal lantern without a solar panel work as a solar lantern?
No. The MATAHUM pair has metal frames and flameless LED candles, but no solar panel and no charging time are stated, so the pair needs 3 AAA batteries per candle and a CR2025 battery for the remote. It suits indoor decor and covered patios, not a solar setup.
Related solar guides
See the solar lantern vs LED camping lantern comparison, the solar table lamp vs solar lantern comparison, the solar lantern vs kerosene lantern guide and the best solar lanterns for hiking.
